<body><script type="text/javascript"> function setAttributeOnload(object, attribute, val) { if(window.addEventListener) { window.addEventListener('load', function(){ object[attribute] = val; }, false); } else { window.attachEvent('onload', function(){ object[attribute] = val; }); } } </script> <div id="navbar-iframe-container"></div> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://apis.google.com/js/platform.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> gapi.load("gapi.iframes:gapi.iframes.style.bubble", function() { if (gapi.iframes && gapi.iframes.getContext) { gapi.iframes.getContext().openChild({ url: 'https://www.blogger.com/navbar/6466083?origin\x3dhttp://artlife.blogspot.com', where: document.getElementById("navbar-iframe-container"), id: "navbar-iframe" }); } }); </script>

the art life

"...it's just like saying 'the good life'".

A Funny Kind of Sad

Saturday, March 15, 2008
From Eve Sullivan...




LIFE IS A LAUGH, the poster says. So oddly quaint, in its restraint, spelt out in faded red block capital letters. Propped up at one end of the station platform amidst scaffolding and construction materials, a stack of old drums, an old caravan, a row of dim light bulbs and a giant panda head, this is all part of Brian Griffiths’ Platform for Art installation at Gloucester Road tube station. Not exactly funny Ha Ha, but more funny as in tragic, sad, like some kind of memorial to an old fairground, that never quite got built. The workers left, the backer pulled out, the people moved on to something else, unless of course you’re passing through the station. Somehow you can’t escape the feeling that someone still lives there, some creepy extras still lurking in the shadows (like the guy in the clown suit doing the runner in time-traveling DI Alex Drake’s recurring nightmare in the BBC’s latest Ashes to Ashes). Likewise, I agree with the comment posted on the Transport for London website: "The giant panda head is the scariest thing I’ve ever seen … please stop this traumatisement."

Brian Griffiths, Platform for Art installation, Gloucester Road Tube.

This is what the Brits do so well, this wry self-deprecatory humour, with a touch of nostalgia. Yep, I loved Dave Allen, The Two Ronnies, Monty Python, The Goodies. I still laugh out loud at re-runs of Fawlty Towers. Those jokes about Manuel and the German tourists – ‘Don’t mention the war!’ – were irony weren’t they? Things have moved on since then. Now that the UK is part of Europe, and the white, Anglo-type experience isn’t all of it, Manuel is more likely to be doing the talking. Unless he’s turned into Mr Bean of course. And, in this era of rampant globalisation, even a smattering of European languages won’t make a dint in it. One way or another we’re all in a strange land, and ever-so-conveniently (if you’re a creative that is) lost in translation.

This, in a nutshell, is what’s behind Laughing in a Foreign Language at the Hayward Gallery, Southbank Centre. Curated by the in-house Japanese Curator, Mami Kataoka, with a little help from Director Ralph Rugoff, humour is the new Esperanto enlisted to promote a common understanding. As we all know, playing gags, lifting jokes, being a tourist and just generally acting up for the camera are the stock-in-trade tricks of the contemporary artist, aimed at claiming our attention for more serious subjects.

The exhibition starts out with South-Korean artist Gimnongsok’s masquerade of a Mexican family paid to don animal suits to enact the fairytale of the Bremen Town Musicians. Chinese artist Jun Yang makes a step by step video instruction aimed at illegal Chinese immigrants trying to blend into Austrian society. The Iranian-born, Paris resident, Ghazel posts up offers of marriage to help asylum seekers obtain a passport. Barthélémy Toguo presents fake wooden suitcases, impossible to open, to get back at the customs officials. But, even putting aside the at times somewhat schoolbook geopolitics, there’s not really much to laugh about here. And, I’m not sure that the earnestness of the theme hasn’t entirely lost out on that old staple – irony.

Matthew Griffin, Rocker. Mixed media, spooky...

In the work of the thirty artists on show, there is a fairly predictable catalogue of themes. There are several sitings of clowns (by Rondinone and Rosefeldt) and various dress-up contingents (as in Marcus Coates’s shaman from Siberia), Australia’s own Matthew Griffin’s Rocker wearing prosthetic, ectoplasmic graffiti and Kutlug Ataman cross-dressing belly dancer (awful indeed). Co-opting others is a major theme. Olaf Breuning shows us the funny, chummy tapes of the guy on the road making friends in Japan, Ghana, Switzerland and PNG, reinforcing the fact that everyone is obliged go along with the western tourist. But like the Finnish artist Roi Varra’s idea of making the most of living in or travelling to exotic locations, the Artist’s Dilemma does seem at times rather spurious: man standing in a dinner suit on the ice, in front of a signpost featuring the choice between Art and Life. And it’s hard to imagine how anyone would agree to participate in his Wet-paint Handshakes.

Which way - art or life? Roi Varra's Artists Dilemma.

The light touch rules here, and sometimes it works, as in Taiyo Kimura’s video clips, one of a guy brushing the teeth of a fish inserted in his mouth, and in another balancing chop sticks on his eyes – all played on a monitor hidden in a laundry basket. Or take the videos of Polish collective Azorro, whose We Like it A Lot one-line statement fits all occasions, as the ultimate art world Yes men , and who in Portrait of a Curator line up various camera shots to get curators, art critics and gallerists unwittingly posing with them in the background.

Jeffrey Vallance, Shag Carpet Relic from Elvis Presley's Jungle Room, Graceland.

Monkey do, monkey don’t. Now it’s the curators who want to get in on the act with the Martian Museum of Terrestrial Art at the Barbican Art Gallery. Conceived from the point of view of the extraterrestrials trying to make sense of contemporary art, this exhibition takes an anthropological approach. The package includes an audio guide, as introduction to the various themes and foundation myths, a Martian alphabet decoder to understand the script, and a novelist (Tom McCarthy) employed to write the catalogue. Not to mention the usual army of writers, researchers, performers and soothsayers of various persuasions, joining in for the public events. Metal lines like circuitry diagrams connect the works up in a map of the universe-style expose of archetypal themes and narratives.

Starting out with the theme of Ancestor Worship Sherrie Levine is represented with her famous bronze-cast Fountain: 5, redoing Duchamp as pure sculpture, ‘a grand piece to them that is most definitely art’. Then there are various totems, including Thomas Hirschhorn’s giant cigarette lighter that, resembling one of those billboards in the round, is covered in reproductions by ‘the founding fathers’, Warhol, Mondrian et. al. Under Kinship, Marc Lombardi’s diagrams unveil the internecine relationships between governments and corporations. While Cornelia Parker, the great defender of Noam Chomsky in her current Whitechapel show, is here included (in the section on Spells and Charms) with her series of heated-up meteorites burnt through the pages of notable landmarks in that most instructive booklet, the London A–Z .

When X marks the spot, Cornelia Parker meteorite-encusted London A-Z

And if you’re into Holy Relics Jeffrey Vallance’s green Shag Carpet Relic from Elvis Presley's Jungle Room, Graceland provided another entry into the mysterious reckonings of the great, the good and the trivial. Under the section on Making Contact Bruce Nauman’s My Name as Though It Were Written on the Surface of the Moon, shows how far you can go with neon. Other space ship themes thrown in for good measure, include a Ham Steinbach shelf with a bust of Star Wars’ R2D2, and Yves Klein’s Pneumatic Rocket hanging from the ceiling.

Exhausting and exhaustive, with its catalogue of themes, and a good deal of work displayed in museum-style vitrines, it’s hard to take in the work of so many artists (115 altogether) while also participating in this spaceship-earth business. Sure, there are lots of big names here. But why are they only interested in what happened between now and fifty years ago? And why so Eurocentric if it’s the whole planet we’re talking about? Where – you might ask – are the face painters and firewalkers? And why didn’t they pick up on some real human toys, guaranteed for art-like obsolescence, to ponder and make up their own mind about? Who is to say, indeed, which way is Art and which way Life. These Martians are clearly too in the know to provide much alternative.

Bruce Nauman’s My Name as Though It Were Written on the Surface of the Moon.

It is with some relief then to go to the Institute of Contemporary Art where a more direct approach has been taken, employing the artist as a Double Agent. According to artist Phil Collins, nothing works better to catch your attention than a slap in the face. His portraits of curators Mark Sladen and Claire Bishop, among others, are taken the moment after their willing submission to this treatment (you can see this in their stunned, arresting expressions, and one-sided pink cheeks). In these and other works involving collaboration, role-playing, and some serious delegation, the artist is also the director.

In one of many ongoing variations on a theme, Barbara Visser in her video Last Lecture employs an actor to play herself, relaying the script through headphones, while maintaining a visible presence in silhouette, and responding to the previously recorded footage involving a different actor and studio audience, and subtitles that don’t match up with what is being said. This is a great watch/read/listen for those like me who thrive on participating in three conversations at once. If you like the idea of giving others a go, to let them make a mess of it while taking not too much responsibility, and a significant proportion of the credit, then the ceramic displays by Pavel Althamer and the Nowolipie Group , an organization for adults with disabilities, provides another case in point. Here, clay biplanes are the go and Althamer tries to make it like it really got off the ground in a plane that looks like an old aluminium saucepan. More provocative, but with nothing left to show for it but the video by Artur Zmijewski of the work as it goes up in flames and gets stomped on, is the workshop between Polish Catholics, Jews, Socialists and Nationalists played out on camera, in another example of this seriously oddball, relational practice.

Havin' a laugh... installation by Pavel Althamer and the Nowolipie Group.

And finally, I can’t go without mentioning the origin of all this chicanery in the work of Duchamp, Man Ray, Picabia at Tate Modern. If, like me, you don’t mind admitting to a certain degree of frustration surrounding the obfuscation, the reverential awe accompanying each annotated versions of the notes to … that surrounds Duchamp’s oeuvre, this exhibition is nothing short of a revelation for its direct approach, its blow-by-blow account of how it all happened as a communication between friends. When the rest of the world just did formalist, these guys were out on their own, copying, egging each other on. Yes, the sex jokes, human=machine, the woman behind the glass and the keyhole, Mona Lisa LHOOQ (everyone did a version), not to mention those late nude paintings (Picabia). Then there are the experiments with optics and cervical, rotational, devices, along with the rayographic advances in photography (Man Ray). And not wanting to be pigeonholed, as just painters or photographers or potentially sullied by the association with such platforms altogether (Duchamp), and working through the various manifestations of the landmark invention of the readymade, and the various position on in-jokes and chess games...


Patrons please wash hands after use.

Labels: , ,

Why So Hot Right Now

Monday, February 04, 2008
From Ian Houston in Sydney...

I'm not ashamed to admit that I love abstract painting. I love the grid, monochromes, gestural works (within reason), hard edge, The New York school I adore De Stijl, and would consider crime to own a Theo van Doesburg. I often think about Rothko's suicide and Pollock's car crash. I hug Modernists and ask them to hurry back. I encourage Abstract Expressionists and say they should stick with it, their time will come again. I once wanted be a Supremacist but didn't make the grade. And I have on occasion painted my own lame "abstract works". So it will surprise no one to know that I loved the Callum Innes show at the MCA. Here's a man who can use a roll of masking tape. A man who worries about the golden mean, who is seriously concerned about whether an edge should be hard or blurry, who contemplates for great periods of time the necessity of adding another colour to the composition. Who can only paint when the canvas is larger than he is. Does it mean anything? Who the fuck knows. But it's a lot closer to the Platonic ideality than Tracey Emin.


Callum Innes, Cadmium orange on white.


Callum Innes like many of his ilk, is in awe of the canvas. His work is flat, lean, contemplative and deals unapologetically with the problems of composition, colour and surface. Many of his works pivot on the tension between the hard edge and the painterly blur, solid forms that rest against areas of dissolute paint, sprayed pigments that stain the surface in soft showers of splattered drops and ragged clouds of colour. The metaphoric resonance of such contrast brings to mind human/nature oppositions in which the accident of the gesture works against, under or through the absolutes of the hard edged forms. If one Googles him you'll find the idea most often referred to in his practice is the notion of "stripping back", creating compositions from exposing what has been, as well what is. Such techniques lend themselves readily to psychological understandings of subtexts and the unconscious, though I prefer to think of it in terms of plays on narrative, teleology and intention, where the painter seeks to show the past within the present, the metaphysical inevitability of the project rendered in colours that could go nicely with your couch.


Callum Innes, Exposed painting vine black

Indeed to make this task easier, Innes has elected to name many of his paintings after the predominant colour used, as in Exposed Painting Dioxazine Violet. This is significant, as the names that abstract artists use often gives us a clue to where exactly their head is at. After all you may have two painters painting hard edge geometrics, but one may be a deeply religious aesthete such as Barnett Newman whilst the other maybe an atheistic conceptualist such as Daniel Buren. That's where nomenclature helps, Newman will give his paintings names such as 12 Stations of the Cross whilst Buren goes for something more straightforward - Painting with variable forms. Interestingly Innes seems to want to play both sides of the road with titles that allude, to a poetic disposition but ultimately remain descriptions of the nature of his practise, such as Monologue seven or Exposed Painting, Veronese Green. I find this interesting. It seems to be at the very heart of his practice, this idea of the poetic being an accident, a failing of discipline. The dribble of paint that escapes, its beauty thrown into relief by the hard edges that surround it.


Callum Innes, Six Identified Forms

Works in the show seem to fall into three modes of expression. Hard edged forms, "exposed" turpentine rubbed canvas and splattered, drip action works. Generally each painting will exhibit some interaction between any two of these modalities with the occasional piece being devoted entirely to the one technique. The discipline of his practise is evident in the highly finished nature of the paintings. Every painting is beautifully glazed, every paint surface ideal, every composition entirely realised. They are deeply satisfying aesthetic objects whose surface leads one to the kind of sublime contemplation that was de riguer in 1991. The softness of the pigment, the clouds of colour, the sense of melting away from the hard edge, the depth of blacks and browns leads one inevitably to thoughts of Rothko. The discipline of the line and its betrayal seem to be a theme. Exposed painting cadmium orange is one of a series in which the taped perfection of the square is transgressed by a leak of thinned paint that continues on its own to map out the trajectory of the composition, the looseness of the dribbling paint contrasted with the tightness of the square. The monologue series are, unsurprisingly monochromes, in which the canvas has been stained, wiped, stained and then dribbled with turps, the wash of the solvent leaving track marks across the canvas in varying degrees of tone. The effect is of a vast landscape in which all detail has been rendered into variations of pigment. This staining, washing and toning of the canvas forms the ground for a number of works in which splatters of enamel paint form sparse figures against this tonal wash. The viscosity of the enamel highlighted by the subtlety of the background.

Innes' work is a kind of philosophical aestheticism in which the effects are achieved through a rigour of composition that seems to appeal to a mystical mathematics. If they are beautiful it is because of their ability to trap the gaze in the rhythms of their logic, the counterpoint between intention and accident, the willed and the circumstantial, trajectory and finish. Like the shows title "From Memory" each work seems to be reaching into time for a perfect moment. An ideal instance of an impossible circumstance. At 46 years of age we can think of Mr Innes as a mid career artist, it will be fascinating to see where his practise leads. More straight lines? Or blurry?

The MCA is so hot right now with Innes and Tim Hawkinson side by side on the top floor, two engaging and successful contemporary artists whose practise couldn't be more different yet each in their own way showing us that the radically catholic nature of contemporary art seems able to embrace just about anything in its all consuming maw. And that goes without mentioning the radical beauty of Shazia Sikander show at the entry level. I recommend a visit.

Labels: , ,

Good Will Art Tour

Tuesday, August 28, 2007
The eternal question – where are we? We’re in Brisbane to talk to Queensland University of Technology students about careers in art writing. It’s raining and its cold and the people in the big mall in the centre of town look annoyed and feral, like a riot is going to break out. At QUT people look neater and less wild, and they are very attentive listeners. They ask perceptive questions and seem amused by the notion that writing about art is a sucker’s game – you can’t make a living out of it.


Digital art - pregnant with meaning.

The QUT event takes place in the campus art gallery and we take a gander at their digital art exhibition, The Vernacular Terrain. It’s not a very exciting show, and for some reason all the digital art has been printed out from a computer and stuck to the walls, just like old art. In QUT’s adjacent gallery space is the all-female Breaking New Ground: Brisbane Women Artists of The Mid-20th Century. The show features work by Margaret Cilento, Pamela MacFarlane, Margaret Olley, Joy Roggenkamp, Kathleem Shillam and Betty Quelhurst. Looking at the works is like taking a stroll through an old text book, perhaps something by Bernard Smith, all brown toned and sepia paintings of bunches of flowers and nudes. The juxtaposition between the two shows is slightly jarring, but a juxtaposition that’s pretty standard museum practice these days. It’s probably not fair to judge both shows by the same standards since they set out to do very different things but we come away from the digital art show thinking that it’s just as well we don’t.

The next day we head over to the Gallery of Modern Art to see if what we experienced at the opening back in 2006 wasn’t a hallucination. We remembered a vast permanent collection of little-seen Australian contemporary art in tall galleries filled with glorious light. When we get there the place is deserted and high winds howl through the sliding glass doors of the book shop sounding like the winds of Armageddon. We have to hold the edges of expensive international art magazines firmly lest they fly from our hands.

Inside the gallery proper, school groups wandered around and the permanent collection looked drab under grey light. Never mind, we thought, there was still the opportunity to see the temporary shows but one of them was the Howard Arkley retrospective touring exhibition that was featured in episode 1 of the Art Life TV series. We spent hours in the Art Gallery of NSW while shooting that show and the last thing we wanted to see was see Arkley’s thin oeuvre yet again. But always game for a reassessment we had a stroll through the show anyway and it didn’t look to bad so long as you didn’t look too long. Arkley’s strongest works – his suburban house exteriors - aren’t represented by his best examples in the retrospective and the urban tribal stuff looks as crappy now as it did back in the 1980s. We’d had some misgivings making the TV show of making Arkley’s biography a part of his artistic story, but standing in front of his picture of the disembodied arm shooting up, you had to at least concede that the artist had made the biography part of the work himself. If only there were a bit more to the story. If only the silly bastard was still alive.

GoMA’s major installation of the moment is by German artist Katharina Grosse. The blurb on the gallery’s website says that “The artist transform[s] GoMA’s long gallery into an extraordinary environment that confounds conventions of museum display and challenges our expectations of painting.” The actual installation is a gob stopper – right in the middle of the gallery’s main space, two massive mounds of dirt have been heaped up against one wall and two equally massive canvas stretchers have been stuck on top. On the opposite wall, from ground level going right up to the top floor, are a series of massive balloons. The mounds of dirt are nearly 20 meters high and the entire installation has been spray painted with various garish colours - green, red, orange and blue. The whole work is – to be blunt – about as dumb and ugly as it is possible to be. The only expectation confounded here is the notion of taste, and we’re not talking about the total lack of any redeeming painterly qualities, but the sheer impoliteness of the artist trying to pass off this hideous eye sore as a “work of art”. What a disgrace.




Outside the wind was even stronger as the effects of a sub tropical storm blasted bone dry Brisbane. We took shelter in the State Library of Queensland. Inside was an exhibition called Reel Rescues. Art shows in libraries tend to be pretty dull affairs but Reel Rescues turns out to be one of the best things we see on our good will tour of the art world. It’s a show of rare films made from the 1920s through to the 1970s, ranging from home movies to news reels. The set up for the show is fairly straightforward – each film is projected onto the wall next to another projection and the effect is like an exhibition of moving paintings. A discreet sound design chimes away in the background and it’s a small joy to walk around in the dark, taking a dip into the grain of the various films stocks, the twitter of Lorikeets and laughing children in the distance. Sometimes things that aren’t supposed to be art achieve the status of art through their sheer indifference to art. What a million pleasurable miles it feels from GoMA.

As we leave Brisbane, reports come in that the south east of Queensland is under water. Up above the clouds, once all the shaking of the plane passes, it is bright and lovely. The woman next door is reading about Katie Holmes and how close friends confide that she is at her wits end with Tom Cruise’s outlandish Scientological theories of child rearing. Not only that, but Katie Holmes is looking haggard while the Scientologists have built a UFO landing strip in Colorado.


Katie Holmes: friends confide the star is close to breakdown over Tom's demands.

A sense of profound unreality sets in as we descend back through the clouds and over the dot designated as our nation’s capital. Canberra airport is an armed camp. Federal cops are conspicuous by their presence; short, bald guys in blue jumpsuits, Glocks on hips and their arms folded sternly as they watch travelers just off the intercity flights looking for their bags. Big rear-lit pro Work Choices ads sit next to large cut away images of amphibious ships that can – according to the image – carry loads of tanks, landing craft, helicopters and assault ‘copters. It’s the logical choice says the advert.


John Brack, Portrait of Kym Bonython 1963.
Oil on canvas.
Collection: National Portrait Gallery.
Canberra Gift of Kym Bonython AC 2007 © Helen Brack


We’re in Canberra to open the John Brack show at the National Portrait Gallery. Our brief is to talk about Brack’s relevance today. The crowd is huge for the opening – four hundred punters crowding around inside Old Parliament House, glasses of excellent merlot being quaffed as various art world, business and social luminaries greet each other. How are we going to explain that John Brack’s work is still relevant, indeed, has always been relevant? We remember our high school art text book – the one written by Kim Bonython – and Brack’s Collins Street 5pm picture staring out at us from the page. No one could have mistaken that image for anything other than art with texture, with history, with an eccentric and idiosyncratic vision. That seems like contemporary art to us, no matter when it was made.


John Brack, Barry Humphries in the character of Mrs Everage, 1969.
Oil on canvas.


The exhibition itself is a beauty. The halls of the NPG are hard to hang works in, but their fusty atmosphere seems perfect for the weirdness that is Brack en masse. His work is reminiscent of graphic art of the 50s, and of Warner Bros. cartoon backgrounds in particular. It’s the black line over green and brown that does it, a sensation rather like the distant ringing of an alarm bell from a bank robbery gone wrong. Brack’s portraits have unexpected echoes – his portrait of Bonython for example is eerily reminiscent of Philip Guston, the lines of the plaid jacket looking like a bag full of oranges threatening to burst, his portrait of Helen Brack recalling Grant Wood and James McNeill Whistler while the acidic portrait of Mrs Edna Everage have little indications within the orange and green folds of the dress the later work of Arkley. Yep, it’s all there.

Contemporary art is obsessed with the meaning and agency of the art object – how it relates to the world and how the art object transmits meaning to an audience. In a lot of contemporary art the idea of the work, its subtlety and nuance, gets lost in that obsession. Brack’s work offers a multi-layered meaning, one that contains humour and irony and deftly deploys those qualities within a painting, that much valued and vaunted of all art objects. Brack’s irony always set him apart from the angst and sincerity of Australia’s expressionists, and if his lack of wins in the bog standard art competitions of the day is any measure, he wasn’t hugely valued by the establishment either. Irony is now in plentiful supply but its cheapness has also devalued its bite. While you can find irony just about anywhere from American sitcoms to redundant political ads, but it takes a real skill to use irony to its richest and fullest variety. It’s a difficult notion to express but if artfully done seems as simple and natural to understand as the act of looking. Brack’s work has it and its effect is like falling into the pull of a giant magnet. You may not like it but it’s mesmerizing.

Labels: , ,

Notional Museum

Wednesday, August 08, 2007
Curiosity drove The Art Life to the National Museum of Australia. How has it weathered the storm of the history wars? Did it survive the intense criticism of its so-called “black armband” view of Australian history and which led to Dawn Casey being “let go” in 2003? In short, have things changed on Acton Peninsula?



The ways in which any of our national cultural institutions use art to tell their stories, and how the history of art fares in the process, is a cultural narrative often as interesting as the contents of such institutions. The way their collections are presented to curious visitors like the Art Life is worthy of some forensic commentary...

Inauspicious is the best we can say about our approach to the NMA. This must be the most exhausted example of fin-de-siecle PoMo architecture in the southern hemisphere. The sign out front tells you how successful it’s been in pulling the tourists, but the peeling pathway (the designer sculpture which supposedly points to Uluru) has had to be modified to save tourists from hurting themselves.



The clunky concrete forms (on which you’re not allowed to skate, ride or board) have been filled in with even clunkier bits of steel. Clearly there’s been no artist involved in its execution, and therefore no Moral Rights at stake.






As you close in, you see how tired is the six year old fabric of the building and its surrounds. It’s visibly rusting, peeling, fading, rotting, and leaking before you ever get to see inside.










And when we looked over the wall at the Garden of Australian Dreams we saw its faded paint and stagnant pool surrounded by features which have been rendered “safe” by other OH&S concerns, thus neutralising its original, sophisticated in-jokes...



...such as the poor Italian alder trees planted at an angle, now struggling to straighten themselves. Or then there’s a forest of other leaning “trees”, poles painted blue, (get it?) outside the Backyard Café, and the new fences strategically installed to prevent the elderly slipping and suing. And yes, even the “water feature” makes it into the pantheon of designer jokes!




This expensive playground is another fertile field for architectural moral rights disputes of the future. No doubt it will prove to be a DIY superannuation scheme for the designers (Room 4.1.3, a.k.a. Richard Weller and Vladimir Sitta) when, in the not so distant future, the Dream fades even more and the whole lot needs to be refurbished.

So we began at the beginning, walking up the stairs to a gallery titled Horizons: the peopling of Australia, which purports to tell the story of first contact, settlement and immigration. Around the first corner we find lots of images which look like Art. Dominant in this ensemble is a portrait of William Dampier, heavily wooden-framed, looking just like the real thing.



But alas we read the plaque on the frame that it's a copy. The snazzy metal plaque tells us:

Captain William Dampier (the first Englishman to land in Australia) Copy of Portrait in the National Portrait Gallery. Presented by John Masefield (Poet Laureate).

So the original must be in the NPG in London, not the one across the Lake. But the NMA label at the front of the display tells us:




Mysterious. Apparently it's a 19th century copy on loan from the NLA. But it's located so far back in the diorama amongst the forest of plaques and display items, you couldn't tell whether or not it's a copy or not, so the authenticity effect works for most viewers. There's another (admitted) replica beside it, an astrolabe, and on either side (yes!) there's real bark paintings. One is by Wanungwamagula Nandjeewara (no date given) a Groote Island artist, and the other is by the great East Arnhem Land painter, Mathaman Marika (Rirratjingu language group, 1965). Phew! So there is real art here after all.



But wait! What’s this in front? Perhaps moral rights are not a problem for anyone at the NMA, for here is a life size replica of another bark painting from the NMA collection (0750.20.23), by “Mungurraway Yirrkala” (sic) also of 1965. But in this case it’s a very good facsimile (they credit the photographer), and the explanatory plaques are screwed straight into it, and little wire frames drilled into it which support (actual) fragments of Chinese export ceramics and other artefacts discovered in Arnhem Land from the time of the Macassan beche-de-mer trade. My goodness, we think, where do the values of authenticity lie hidden in such sophisticated curatorial subterfuges?

So we look to the labels. As you do. Asking, how should a National Museum account for the relation between authentic artefacts, and replicas? Ambiguously, as it turns out…

We move across the gallery towards the section which describes colonial settlement, past various archaeological artefacts, images of explorers, and illustrations derived from contemporaneous paintings, prints and other images, as well as some things not identified at all.



Here, with relief, we recognise some old favourites, images by the Port Jackson Painter, William Westall, Thomas Watling, and Robert Cleveley, all hung together and neatly framed with a nineteenth century ambience.





While the label suggests authenticity (quote: Port Jackson: a Native by William Westall, National Library of Australia), should they be framed like that without mattes, their paper squished up against the glass? No, but it doesn’t matter, because when you look really closely, you see that they’re only photographic reproductions. Does it say so on the label? No it doesn’t…



Alarmed, we ask ourselves, are there any works of art at all in this Museum? Well, we remember, there were those funny looking painting-like things hanging on that curvy ceilings on the way in – but they had no labels, no attribution, so we didn’t take them seriously. They are, we discovered later, “ceiling banners”, commissioned designs by four contemporary artists. We assumed (correctly its seems) they were décor, ambience building, suggesting the presence of art, without the risk of the real thing. Maybe they were sound baffles, or maybe installed to distract from the appalling lighting fixtures…



So off we go looking for works of art. We find lots of historical artefacts, coins, medals, tools, stuffed animals, clothing, cars, and millions of labels, plinths, and display devices everywhere. Actually, we guessed there are about three or four display objects or images for every authentic artefact. But that’s about normal for an effective theatre of display in such institutions.

But we find no art, in the sense that a work of art usually connotes originality, authorship, authenticity, the idea of art in the mind of its originator. Except we do find a small ceramic sculpture by the Adelaide funk artist Margaret Dodd FJ Holden Pretending to be an Australian Native Porcupine (1982), on loan from the Art Gallery of South Australia, sitting on a plinth next to a real FJ Holden. A strange inversion of contextualisation to be sure.


Margaret Dodd, FJ Holden Pretending to be an Australian Native Porcupine, 1982.
Loan from the Art Gallery of South Australia.


Around the corner, illustrating the theme of suburbia, there’s a handkerchief-sized reproduction of a Howard Arkley painting of 1994 (courtesy of Tolarno Galleries). And a little further on there is an example of what appears to be folk art, a life-sized emu made of barbed wire, with a label: "Barbed Wire Emu. Made by Laurie Nilsen, cast aluminium, Barbed wire, and steel, National Museum of Australia", but giving no time or place of production or other attribution.

But once we turn into the West Wing (the museum is a horseshoe shaped building) where we’ve entered the Gallery of the First Australians, we see artworks everywhere, from all historical periods, forms, materials and functions. Here we encounter a myriad of Indigenous objects, artefacts, and works of art from the earliest known examples, to the recent past. There’s a contemporary exhibition in the Focus Gallery "70% Urban: an exhibition exploring the growth of Urban Indigenous culture across Australia", and a Gallery of Torres Strait and Islander art. Each example of indigenous artefact or work of art is surrounded, as before, with a multitude of exhibition devices, images, and interpretive texts, providing the contexts, origins, and indigenous identity of the artist. As we would expect of works of art in a national museum. And, while in this wing facsimiles are identified as such, other attributions are not as accurate as they might be.

As we walk back through the Museum, a powerful sense of ennui overwhelms us. How, we ask ourselves, are we expected to understand the rich examples of authentic Indigenous art forms when they are so profoundly decontextualised by the absence of other (actual) works of art in the rest of the Museum?

Perhaps, we speculate, this is a bizarre consequence of the unusual circumstances of the Museum’s creation, and the events which followed? The motivation for a national Museum was built, opportunistically, on a set of existing collections inherited by the Federal Government, brought together under one roof as a project to celebrate the Centenary of Federation. Unlike other State Museums, or the Powerhouse Museum, it was put together in a hurry, without the long histories of up to a century of collecting history of the other institutions.

In every other review or report on the nature of the NMA collection, the richness of the collections of Indigenous art, the core collection of which was once housed in the (then) Institute of Anatomy just up the road, plus the Aboriginal Arts Board collection, has been celebrated for its depth and distinctiveness. In a relatively short period of time in the 90s it was brought up to date by collecting urban Aboriginal art, some of which was produced in the Sydney Art Schools of the eighties. The overall museological context is, however, one of a discordant mix of historical artefacts, replicas, subterfuges, jokes, props, entertainment, too-clever architectural conceits and distracting design devices.

The effect is devastating for both Indigenous and non-Indigenous art. Without an appropriate cross-cultural context to demonstrate the care, consideration, interpretation, recognition and presentation of works of art, by which a national history might be told, the treasures of the Indigenous collection have been reduced to the status of historical artefacts. Just like the FJ Holdens, stuffed kangaroos, Victa lawnmowers, or worse, the ambiguously identified facsimiles, the implicit claim for all the Indigenous artefacts as “works of art” is thrown into question. Or, conversely, the status of all the Indigenous works of art is reduced to that of the historical artefact.

Thus the desired historical national narrative falls apart, not through a “black armband” account of history, but through an imaginative blindspot, a series of theatres of charade, resulting in a cultural incommensurabilty unwittingly constructed across the racial divide.

The Art Life is despondent. As our National Museum, we conclude that the place is an embarrassment. The presentation of its collections of artefacts, and the historical or national narrative it affirms, has lurched from controversy to farce through ideological correctness, through subsequent political interventions, to an complete absence of curatorial imagination and the resultant museological sleights of hand. Unfortunately, the loss is ours.

Labels: ,