<body><script type="text/javascript"> function setAttributeOnload(object, attribute, val) { if(window.addEventListener) { window.addEventListener('load', function(){ object[attribute] = val; }, false); } else { window.attachEvent('onload', function(){ object[attribute] = val; }); } } </script> <div id="navbar-iframe-container"></div> <script type="text/javascript" src="https://apis.google.com/js/platform.js"></script> <script type="text/javascript"> gapi.load("gapi.iframes:gapi.iframes.style.bubble", function() { if (gapi.iframes && gapi.iframes.getContext) { gapi.iframes.getContext().openChild({ url: 'https://www.blogger.com/navbar/6466083?origin\x3dhttp://artlife.blogspot.com', where: document.getElementById("navbar-iframe-container"), id: "navbar-iframe" }); } }); </script>

the art life

"...it's just like saying 'the good life'".

Curiously Enough - It Don't Add Up Part 2

Sunday, August 16, 2009
Last week's post It Don't Add Up was a contribution from a reader, an actual doctor in an actual university who knows about such things. The reader's point was simple - the formula for the creation art didn't quite mean what the Biennale of Sydney thinks it means.

Kaz Maslanka dropped by to alert Art Life readers to a post-in-reply at the group blog Mathematical Poetry. According to the blog's headache-inducing upper case mission statement:

...mathematical poetry is an artistic expression created by performing mathematical operations on words or images as if they were numbers. One may find this baffling because it seems we are confused about knowing the difference between the states of quality versus quantity. But it is through the fusion of this dichotomy that mathematical metaphor is spawned. Mathematics has always been used for denotation. However, our interest is to use math as a language for connotation.


Okey doke. So, bracing ourselves for a set-to, we clicked on the link to find the following [plus a complete repost of our own words, so we now return the favour]:

Problems Encountered With Mathematical Poetry

Here is a perfect example of why mathematical poetry will have problems at least in the near future. In the [Art Life] blog entry [...] the author is complaining that the originator for a set of equations published in the brochure for the Biennale of Sydney is numerically illiterate. Curiously enough I think they should have said mathematically illiterate for numbers are not involved in these examples. That said, I am not sure that it is true that the originator was mathematically illiterate as well. The author claims that the expression, “Art = tyranny” is a false statement yet, historically there has been countless examples of art that has been inspired by or executed to express tyranny. A good example would be the artistic turmoil created around 1911 in Zurich Switzerland, for the entire Dada movement’s intention was to be tyrannical (Anti-Art)… as well as the copy cats that came after. Obviously the problem brought to question in this brochure is how one reads an equation. Is the equation to be read as poetry or science? Too many people think that an equation is automatically scientific in its expression. If this myopic attitude is left to continue, mathematics will be in denotative chains forever. When one reads poetry one searches for the proper context to give it meaning in relation to their life. One looks at the many facets of a poem to see what it is pointing to. “Art = tyranny” is a perfect expression for Dada, Punk or any other nihilist form or art.

Now to give our author the benefit of the doubt we could agree with him/her if the originator’s intention was scientific however, I can hardly see scientific intent in this expression even if it were meant to be.


An intention not to break the law doesn't excuse someone from breaking the law, does it? [We heard that on CSI once, and it sounded good...]

Labels: , ,

The Possibility of an Island

Thursday, July 31, 2008
From Bonny Dot Cassidy...

The 2008 Biennale of Sydney Cockatoo Island “branch” has now exceeded its anticipated visitation by 5,000 people, and we should expect that figure to continue climbing through August. Sidling over the waves toward the Island, my companion R and I mused on the pros and cons of the detached exhibition space. It says, at once, keep away and come hither. As with that other convict rock, Tasmania, it’s tempting to read the island venue as a metonym of the island-continent itself. Is it Australian art, floating within biennales the world over; or is it the Sydney Biennale, surfacing again from the calendar of international art events? Thankfully, though, the reality of the exhibition at Cockatoo Island dispels this nonsense. It represents a spectrum of countries, and draws visitors into a surging odyssey that goes well beyond a neatly symbolic experience of art.


William Kentridge, What Will Come (Has Already Come), 2007.
35mm film transferred to video, 8:40 mins, 118 cm diameter

It takes roughly six hours to see all the works here, so we weren’t entirely sure what voyagers on the mid-afternoon ferry were hoping to take on. To be fair, it’s impossible to know what one is in for until one has arrived; or to know how hard it will be to leave until mid-way through the adventure. The best time to go is a mid-week morning, armed with free yellow map and a picnic (the café is stuck over at the wharf, far from many of the works, and selling overpriced tea and brownies). I don’t know how disabled visitors are supposed to access Cockatoo Island, nor does the Biennale seem to know; the venue quit being used for festivals last year because of its dormant hazards, and it’s hard to imagine what kind of insurance scheme could possibly cover them. Nevertheless, speaking for my able-bodied self, I love the twists of piping and wire that press into shoe soles; the winding paths to the upper, colonial levels of the island (yes, the higher you ascend the deeper in time you go); the sandstone dust and oozing walls; the staircases that go bump in the dark. But they are the detritus of deeper encounters with discomfort, and if I had to reduce Cockatoo Island to a generic form it would be a kilometre-square endurance work that sucks at every drip of the place’s dark history.

Depending on the direction of the hooting wind, everyone will be held by a different work out here. The praises of William Kentridge’s pair of son et lumière creations have now become universally sung in critical reviews and pub conversations alike. Like many of the Island’s installations, the smaller What Will Come (Has Already Come) is so organically framed and positioned that it might as well be site-specific. The same can certainly be said for Mike Parr’s survey of video performances, Mirror/Arse, housed in the old sailors’ quarters and naval academy. It is a haunting interrelation of space and materials.

Entry to the quarters is policed but, like other “guarded” precincts on the Island, we found that regulations had become rather slippery. R observed that a gaggle of kids had somehow entered the adults-only building; and, despite the volunteer’s polite request to leave via the entry, I nearly took several exits that freely lead out to god-knows-where. Perhaps it’s this fine balance of rule and anarchy in Parr’s quarters that really gripped me. Take sound, for instance: Parr’s videos are not sound-scaped, that is, aurally designed. But wandering the sailors’ corridors, often blind to the images that lay behind particular doors, I realised the significance of their soundtracks. His hoofing, puffing, slicing and intaking—sounds of actual pain, endurance, shock and relief—become a voice for the walls of the building.

And the building is thick with the fug of a male domestic space. Every spectator of Mirror/Arse is trespassing—into private rooms and cul-de-sacs and toilets and stairwells—but for the female visitor there is a second threshold to cross. Here, a spew of work clothes; there, like pin-ups for monks, are mysterious reproductions of second-rate romantic artworks or a Virgin Mary. Now, industrial kitchens disused, forgotten, collapsed; now, bathrooms like gas chambers. And the constant, matted bits of down and birds, where men and animals have ferreted about together. In some of the empty rooms, I forgot all about Parr and became sad as I looked over the harbour—to other islands or Drummoyne cranes, all turning distantly and silently beyond the glazed windows.

In Vernon Ah Kee’s occupation of a nearby unionists’ toilet block, Parr’s filled silence, his primal screams, are articulated in signs. These two works are sibling spaces. In fact, in my memory I have attached the toilets to the sailors’ quarters rather than to theweathergroup_U’s warehouse space. But these, says R, were not the sailors; they were different men, different times, who scrawled their curses and jokes and tags over the urinal walls and cubicle doors. Ah Kee, he says, has celebrated their political frustration by simply presenting the block in its existent state and without commentary. But I don’t feel any curiosity for these bitterly misogynist and bigoted doodles as historical artefacts. All I feel is the briny pressure of the urinal block, a leering presence over my shoulder, the wind coming in and in and in.

Ah Kee has, to varying interpretation, turned the toilet block back over to its custodians; and the point of Parr’s installation is to turn the only trace of his performances—video—back into physicality. It’s intriguing, then, to consider the aesthetic theory of David Elliott, who has just been announced as director of the 2010 Sydney Biennale. “Art runs parallel to life”, he told the Sydney Morning Herald (July 29, 2008), “it’s not the same thing as life and that distance is what gives it its power”. For what a piece of work is Cockatoo Island; that, while it first appears to be defined by distance, it is in fact an experience of proximity and immediacy. Ah Kee and Parr are saying something contrary to Elliott: the aesthetic is not a “parallel” space of play, just as the unionists’ graffiti is not locked in its context. Are we ready for the velocity that strikes when the white wall between life and art is torn down?

Labels:

Time Travel

Thursday, July 17, 2008
Following on from her exhibition preview Isobel Johnston returns with this report on the Biennale, for real...

This year's Biennale of Sydney is a demonstrably rigorous curated exhibition involving 180 artists over several physical locations and online. Not that didacticism per se is what I’m arguing for but the show works wonderfully as a teaching tool - a visually constructed academically tight means of being teleported back and forth through the canon of art history managing something rather greater than lip service to areas previously occluded. And here we’re talking peripheries and centres not just social, economical, racial etc but artistic - those that had been there but somehow eluded the art history books.


William Kentridge, What Will Come (Has Already Come), 2007.
35mm film transferred to video, 8:40 mins, 118 cm diameter

I haven’t seen everything but I’ve been taking various groups to the AGNSW, MCA and Cockatoo Island and Artspace and will be visiting Pier 2/3 in the coming weeks. Sight, sound and space all feature in this show and the use of Cockatoo Island for primarily video based works was a clever move as the site is and of itself overpoweringly charged - with massive industrial scale buildings, abandoned machinery and colonial history (not to mention very aggressive seagulls). The magic of encountering William Kentridge’s video pieces echoing back to social and politically states of being, silhouettes of nursery rhymes and Russian literature from the swirling anamorphic form to their syphoned reality creates a glimpse of how history works as they coalescence from the amorphous to the clearly visible.

The thing that might be seem to be missing in this Biennale is the ‘wow’ factor. But this is a hard thing to quantify and maybe if you hang around the arts for long enough you become a bit too jaded or just plain old. But I do remember having my socks knocked off by encountering works in past biennales – Nam June Paik’s TV sets, encountering Sophie Calle’s work , or Doris Salcedo’s shoes and it’s quite possible in the future I will recall Giuseppe Penone’s bronze tree, William Kentridge’s anamorphic animated drawings and participating in the Stuart Ringholt’s anger workshop. That was a strange encounter - one which I entered into rather sceptically and in retrospect considered more seriously. Historically there have been parallels and overlappings of art and hysteria or general madness, mentally instability- everybody loves a nutter like the Van Gogh or Louise Bourgeois or Mike Parr - you’d have to be a little strange or awfully sane to spend so many years exploring the threshold between the contained and the uncontained body - from vomit to piss. But apart from the few who really want to address this within their art and all those that reveal far more of it than they ever intended in their art practice but by and large we want to act fairly sane in public life. I had thought I’d just go through the motions and help the artist out by participating while remaining quite aloof from the whole process. But later in the day I experienced a kind of emotional backwash – though I’m not too sure what kind of public confession I really want to make here. Nonetheless I was forced to admit it did make me think.


Pierre Huyghe, A Forest of Line, 2008.
24 hour event in the Concert Hall at Sydney Opera House for the 16th Biennale of Sydney


So there may well be some lasting retinal retention – which is the best means I have of gauging the importance of a work- it’s almost like a slide show where I call recall works that really work for me in the mind’s eye - associated with this Biennale too where I can replay William Kentridge in my mind, recall the cold hug of the Pernone tree and see myself screaming caught in the carpeted space in the AGNSW or standing in a rainforest where the Opera House once stood.

I’ve yet to book in for a talk with Ross Gibson and may have left it too late. But I’m still recovering from ambushing Kentridge in the MCA where like a dag I said how much I liked his work. If I’d said anything else I’m sure he’d have been happy to continue a conversation but little else works better as a conversation stopper than a sycophantic opening line. But I gather that I wasn’t the only fool to corner him like that and in fact a groovy young arts person fessed up to saying not only did she tell him how much she liked his work she said “she squealed ‘oh my god it’s like meeting Picasso’.”

The great thing is that the Biennale is on for enough time to drift back to see work, to visit sites on different occasions and in the company of different people. This slower than usual experience of an exhibition adds to the audience’s engagement with both the works and the ideas. A sense of unfolding through time was felt in the Opera House’s main hall which had been converted into a forest of mist and tropical trees by French artist Pierre Huyghe. Reclaiming the foreshore like a drowned world may not be too far away if the climate change that is predicted happens but that idea of nature reclaiming ground especially in the tropics echoes through the work. Sound too lingers through the Biennale – it is a link to past and future times adding yet another dimension to recall. Take the ferry to Cockatoo Island it’s free, make sure you go back while it’s on to see the works that stirred you and take along a friend to share the memory with.

Labels:

Mad, Batty...

Vienna Parreno picks favourite works from the Biennale of Sydney at the Museum of Contemporary Art...


David Medalla, Exploding Galaxies.

In the preface of Exploding Galaxies, the title of Guy Brett's monograph on David Medalla, Dore Ashton speaks of "impractical visionaries", and proceeds to ask- was there ever a practical visionary? It's a kind of apology in the tone of someone who knows full well that the word "visionary" has gone out of vogue. The way words such as "revolution", "lyrical" and "soulful" seem to have gone out of hip usage as well. She proceeded to write a wonderful essay on him anyway, seeing value in reclaiming or rather, standing by the concept.


David Medalla, Cloud Canyon.

Cloud Canyons is probably one of Medalla's most well known work, a seminal piece in kinetic sculpture. His practice has always been protean though (performance, participatory installations, land works, drawing, painting, impromptus, ephemerals and so on) perhaps out of necessity to prevent a certain boredom from settling in, or in the context of a semi-nomadic migrant artist (born in Manila but based in London, New York and Paris) the conscious strategic rejection of pinning down that can quickly turn into death by mannerism or cultural stereotype and classification that is easy to digest and therefore easy to discard.

Miroslav Tichy - his daily inventory of a hundred soft and badly cropped images taken with various homemade cameras. Ultra low-tech made from bits of pieces of string and cardboard with a work practice producing possibly some of the worst archival quality prints known to man. A crazy old charismatic bat of the first order (the hour long documentary is a must) – oblivious to fads and trends, possibly this Biennale thing he's in. Actually forget the photographs – he's the artwork.

Do you like this Biennale? Yes. A lot. Despite the nostalgia? Probably because of it…

Labels: , ,

Where was Philip Guston?

Too much history? Not enough? Rory Dufficy contemplates the inclusion - and exclusion - of particular historical works in this year's Biennale of Sydney...

The much cricticised decision by Biennale curator Carolyn Christov-Bakargiev to include works from the backrooms of various Australian galleries – an inconsequential Malevich drawing, a spectactularly useless sketch of Spiral Jetty by Robert Smithson – was not, I think, a bad one. What it enabled was for her to construct a very particular narrative, with a very particular endpoint, and with a very particular conception of "revolution" (a highly suspicious concept, used aesthetically, and my every use of the word should be assumed to contain these qualifying inverted commas).


Philip Guston, East Tenth, 1977.
Oil on canvas, 203x255cms.
Collection: Art Gallery of New South Wales

It is perhaps unsurprising that a curator based in Turin would lean so heavily on a Eurocentric conception of revolution, and, in particular, on the primary post-war revolution from Italy, arte povera. What is noticibly absent is a focus on post-war revolutions in the anglophone world – in particular, of course, the United States. While it could be argued that the stories and counter stories of AbEx, Colour Field, Pop, Minimalism etc have been heard many times and constitute a sort a hegemonic discourse about post-war avant-guarde art - there is much to be said for the deconstruction of Greenbergian progress – Christov-Bakargiev is not a curator afraid of the obvious, as evidenced by her inclusion of Duchamp’s Bicycle Wheel readymade, and clearly believes in outlining a sort of history of 20th century aesthetic revolutions, which is, in part, helpfully done for her by Lia Perjovschi’s work, Mind Map (Diagram).

There is nothing wrong with a curator outlining her own vision of the course of post-war art, and understandable that many American artists will be underrepresented due to the unavailability of works. What seems clear, though, is that Christov-Bakargiev’s aversion to painting stretches further back than her lack of interest in contemporary painting. The argument for largely excluding contemporary painting from Bienalles seems solid, in that painting, being the most marketable form of art, finds a natural home in commercial galleries (although this argument is less solid for international artists that one might wish to see more of, like, say, Neo Rauch). What seems strange is that Christov-Bakargiev has chosen to ignore post-war painting almost entirely. An obvious example that might have been included is Cy Twombly’s Three studies from the Temeraire, which normally hangs in the Art Gallery of NSW foyer but which had to moved to make way for Nedko Solakov’s A Life (Black and White) .

More conspicuous, at least to me, was the exclusion of anything by Philip Guston, of whose work the AGNSW has a number of fine examples. While any Biennale viewer could ride the escalators down to the twentieth century galleries and see this work, it would seem to speak to Christov-Bakargiev’s general lack of interest in painting that Guston’s work – a true revolution from figuration to abstraction and back to figuration – was not included in her historical survey, especially as she’s willing to include such meaningless work from artists like Smithson. Guston’s work is also revolutionary in a more metaphorical sense: the junkman’s son retreats into himself and, in feat of properly mythological self-examination, decides to paint like, in Hilton Kramer’s famous words, a ‘stumblebum’; he confronts entrenched establishment abstraction with a coarse drunken line and a direct taking-stock of contemporary poltics, something which was verboten amoung the flat mandarins of the New York School. That he did all this and had perfectly appropriate left-wing politics (something which is, admittedly, not particularly conspicuous in the AGNSW’s holdings) should have ensured him a place.

Indeed, his exclusion says something interesting about the position of painting in contemporary art, particularly figuritve painting, and the difficulty that some curators and critics, educated in the high conceptualism, have in evaluating the position of high-quality contemporary painting, even if, as in Guston’s work, there are plenty of obvious jumping-off points for windy critical exegeses. But Guston’s work does more than just pose politically, it does what all good painting does, which is be itself. As interesting psychologically (and, of course, aesthetically) as his Ku Kux Klan and Nixon paintings are, Guston’s late work reveals itself most in the absolute thinghood of his beer bottles, his leather shoes, his bulbous bowls of cherries and his cartoon cigarettes. Guston carefully caresses the detritus of modernity, and is not afraid of nostalgia, just as he is not afraid of gradiloquence and not afraid of bathos. His fearlessness means that even when his work leans in these directions it retains an authoritative honesty – every object seems to jump out of the canvas and declare its being.

Proust, in an interview of 1913, called style "a quality of vision, the revelation of the particular universe that each of us sees and that no one else sees. The pleasure an artist offers us is to convey another universe to us". Guston certainly did this and in that respect maybe he’s not so revolutionary after all.

Labels: , ,

Full Blown Christov-Bakargiev

The Art Life's special on The Biennale of Sydney goes to air on ABC1 on Tuesday July 22 at 10pm. We feature a number of interviews but due to the constraints of the documentary's 27 minute duration those conversations have been edited down to just a few minutes each. We're happy to be able to present our complete interview with The Biennale's artistic director Carolyn Christov-Bakargiev...


TAL: What will someone experience when they come to the biennale?

Carolyn Christov-Bakargiev: Well, there are many audiences and many kinds of people who will experience, hopefully, many different things. I think a good exhibition is one where people walk away with different things, and therefore the exhibition engenders a kind of discussion and conversation. And echoes like ripples in water. I do believe that they should hopefully, come away with a lot of questions. I don't give answers, I ask questions.


Carolyn Christov-Bakargiev, artistic director, Biennale of Sydney 2008.
Photo: Gary Grealy

TAL: Who is the Biennale for?

CC-B: Well I usually say if my mother in law and my daughter like it, it probably is a good piece of art, because it’s very hard to achieve that. So I suppose I'm interested in people who are not necessarily experts in contemporary art. I'm interested in people who go to art the way that they will go to a film, or read a novel. And it’s about finding a space of respite or a space of freedom, or a space of challenge of your stereotype views of whatever. So you do it to find a form of emancipation. So I guess my audience is, is everyone that feels they need that experience. It’s a space of radical freedom that we don't have in our society. We are always thinking about organised work and productivity and organised leisure time, and even going on a holiday is a job. So it’s something that’s not leisure and it’s not work. It’s something else that is making your brain feel alive and making your emotions and your brain work together.

TAL: Did you know much about Australia before you came out here?

CC-B: No, to be totally honest, I must say I knew what I could know through literature and films and um, stories people would tell. I had come however, I have an interesting memory of doing some shows here, some exhibitions here including the William Kentridge at the MCA. And then I brought the Arte Povera collection from our museum, the Castello di Rivoli in Turin to Sydney as well. So there was a working relationship but I remember that those times were very hectic. I came, installed and worked, worked, worked and then left. So this Biennale has given me the opportunity to learn a lot more.

TAL: What do you know now?

CC-B: Ha! Well I'm hesitant to make judgements and pass opinions on a place that I know so little about. And I've come now over the last two years quite a bit and have been living here over the last months. So I can give you the impressions of someone who is an outsider, I cannot give you a really knowledgeable impression. So that said, I think it’s a wonderful – one the one hand it’s a fantastic country in terms of the nature and the way that the harbour – the way that the landscape mixes and blends with the urban. And there are very few places in the world, and I know a lot of big cities, a lot, where you don't have terrible problems of smog and the – it’s just unhealthy. I mean most large cities in the late 20th century and early 21st look like what London must have looked like at the time of the industrialisation in the late 1700s.

TAL: What are your impressions of Australian artistic community?

CC-B: It’s interesting that you ask that because the firs thing I did as a curator of the Biennale was not to buy a ticket and go to Shanghai, it was to go to Tasmania. So my first studio visits were in Hobart actually. Which is a little unconventional for the director of the Sydney Biennale to do that, as the first set of studio visits. But I was very curious to learn about what was going on here. And I found that there is an enormous, really a very, very rich cultural field here. And many artists that are good, and that are under-recognised internationally for a number of reasons. Not only young artists, not only emerging artists, but older eminent figures that are fantastic, you know. And so I guess the distance and – it was quite difficult in the past for the communications before the internet, it was a little harder for things to get around. So I believe that here's a lot to do in terms of having that knowledge of – not only Australian - but also very interesting avant-garde and experimental work in New Zealand, too. So the whole area is really interesting. It’s a society that has many aspects to it, it has of course it’s history as a colonisation of British and the fact of it being a prison, you know, the largest prison that Europe ever built was here. And this prison was made six months before the storming of the Bastille or maybe nine months before, it was in the autumn of 1788. So if you think that the storming of the Bastille is in July ’89, it’s a kind of an expression of a neurotic behaviour of Europe, let's say. So that history is of course I think still present in the culture today. There is a lot of self repression and self inhibition, there's a lot of wanting to be proper. And so the artists are sometimes breaking out of that wanting to be proper, in a way that you don't have in maybe other places that don't have that history.

TAL: Does the distinction between indigenous and non indigenous artists have any meaning for you?

CC-B: Ho, well, let's put it this way. The relationship between indigenous Australians and Australians of western descent or more recently other areas of the world is a very, very complicated and fraught with contradiction. And sad and tragic relationship. It’s absolutely unresolved. It’s one of the aspects of my time here that has been most... fascinating is not the word, because it’s been a tragedy. But engaging emotionally. I've made a lot of friends that are actually in the Aboriginal community. I don't like the term indigenous because it’s a genetic term, it means from – genetically from the place, I don't like that. And I don't like the word Aboriginal either because it’s a European word that means ab-origine, there from the beginning. So you're there from the beginning only if you're defined there from the beginning by somebody else who’s not been there from the beginning. Otherwise you're just a person. So I don't even know how to speak this conflict, and this contradiction, I cannot speak it, there is no language to speak it. I think that the culture produced by this conflict is extraordinary, ranging from curators like Hetty Perkins or Keith Munroe, Brenda Croft to poets and writers like Romaine Moreton who will be doing a fantastic spoken word reading of her poems that she's writing for the Biennale. To artists, there's many, many artists that are, let's call them of the – originally of the place. Let's call it that way. Vernon Ah Kee, Richard Bell, Destiny Deacon, Tracey Moffat. But I didn't do it on purpose. The thing that I really find wrong as a curator is to frame and bracket communities, or groups. So as a feminist I've never done an exhibition of art by women, it think that's anti-feminist to do that. I mean I would never do an exhibition about the sensibility of an – only artists who are gay, for example, I would never do that, I find that racist, I find that wrong. So my way of being um, against those ah … inequalities which I think there are, my way of doing it is not to, to isolate and celebrate, I think that’s hypocritical. But to break the boundaries and bring together, that's what I like to do.


Joan Jonas, Reading Dante, 2008.
Performance for the 16th Biennale of Sydney 2008 at the Cell Block Theatre.

TAL: Is revolution possible?

CC-B: Of course. It has always been and will always be. Every society feels that there will be no more trouble and it never was. I being in Italy know that very clearly because of the history of the Roman Empire. It’s natural to society.

TAL: Why do you think in the last 20 years the idea of revolution has become marginalised?

CC-B: It has been marginalised and mainstreamed at the same time. So I think in the age of the internet it is very hard to control people. In the age of cell phones there's more mobility so the ideology has been – infused into people that if they do anything that’s rebellious it will be bad for the society. So suddenly anybody who does anything is a terrorist or anybody who does anything to change things radically – you know, Charlie Perkins, one of the greatest activists in the Aboriginal movement in Australia, he said, sometimes you have to break rules. There are people under trees that don't have food. You clarify your objective. This is what I say,- you clarify your objective and act accordingly. History has always done that. And so today I think people are afraid of change. Change has been ushered into a consumer culture notion, so change is about fashion. But you know, anybody who knows anything of how the human psyche is developed and develops, knows that it develops also in the child, in the baby through stages. One of those stages is breaking things, you know, it’s the learning and testing limits and breaking things. And it’s a very important impulse to do things that you're not supposed to do. But historically and socially it’s a philosophical question. You cannot change a system from within the system, it’s impossible. So there are limits – you can change a little bit, like micro changes. But you always hit a point where something is not constitutional. So societies have always gotten to a point where to make change you have to go against the rules that that society had implemented, whether it’s the ancient Egyptian pharaohs or you know, a community in Africa somewhere or Rome or London. It’s normal, it’s natural.

TAL: How does the work in the Biennale engage with this idea?

CC-B: I think all art, when it’s good, is revolutionary. All art is about questioning paradigms and breaking paradigms, you think you cannot make a canvas without a figure, ha, let's revolutionise that idea. And Malevich makes the black square. Um, the reason why certain revolutionary things happen in art is always about experimenting through from. And experimenting through language, how we live, how we construct knowledge. So it is about every one of us. So if you take the Malevich example, you are in a society that was suddenly flooded by photography, the new big medium, photography becomes something oppressive suddenly because you have police photography being born and so on and forth. Phrenology, phrenological developments that turned into what they turned into in the 1930s and ‘40s, as we all know the tragedies of that. So you have an artist saying, no zero degree, blank, I will not communicate anything that is figurative because I am questioning that world of the photograph. So there's always an indirect social relationship you know between art and society. But what I think I'm trying to say is through the works of the contemporary artist there are about fifty wonderful works that are new works by young artists. There are also new works by very old artists, there are works by artists who are not alive. I want to break the boundary also that a biennale has to be young artists, who says that. But I want that energy in it as well. There are many, many works that are exploring this question of revolution that to me has to be a revolution of form. A revolution in the language first and foremost. And a revolution in the body, in the way that the viewer smells, you know what you smell when you're in the Mike Parr installation. That's important.


Nedko Solakov, A Life (Black & White), 1999. Installation view.
Black and white paint; 2 workers/painters constantly repainting the walls of the exhibition space in black and white (in rotation) every day for the entire duration of the exhibition.


TAL: What do you say to people who come to the Biennale expecting to see a lot of paintings?

CC-B: Well there are some, there are some paintings. What is a painting? It depends, what is a painting? The definition of painting changes. Nedko Solakov is fantastic artist from eastern Europe. He’s painting with volunteers who are painting for three months of the whole exhibition, the lobby of the art gallery of NSW. One person is painting it black every day the other person is painting it white every day. And they're following each other in a circle. So that’s painting, it’s absolutely painting.

TAL: A lot of works in the biennale put an emphasis on experience or creating a relationship between the artist and the audience. Is this work something you were looking at for this Biennale?

CC-B: I think all good art is participatory. It must create a relationship with the audience. If you're walking into a cave and there's a cave painting.

TAL: But, you know what is meant by participation?

CC-B: I sort of do but, at the same time there's no high tech participatory interactive work in this biennale, I'm kind of against those things. They don't usually, they're not usually based on a true freedom of the viewer. But participation... It’s just that for me it’s difficult because all the work I've ever done has been like that, so it doesn't stand out as anything particular to me because of my background, I guess coming from Arte Povera. I come from that history, if you go backwards, I come from loving the Dada theatre and the Futurist theatre, and so those were all participatory works. I come from clothes that the futurists would make that people were supposed to wear. And so my whole history as a curator or as an intellectual has always been about complete sensorial involvement. So even in a video installation, I will never judge it only by the images in the video. It’s always about where the screen is in relation to the body of the viewer, and where the sound is coming from in relation to the body of the viewer, it’s always about the body of the viewer in relation to something – I don't think the art work exists in its materiality, there – the artwork only exists in that relationship between something that’s a prompt for the artwork and someone who’s experiencing it. So in that relationship between the prompt and the person experiencing, there is something that goes on, and that's the artwork. And it’s immaterial, it’s emotional, it’s sensorial, it’s bodily, it’s physical. But I don't think it’s something that it is particularly of our time. There are things that are of our time. For example, these a lot of performance going on now. It has to do with censorship for example, there's a lot of performance in countries where you’ve got to do it really fast before somebody notices what you’ve done. So this is just done. And performance allows you that. It also has to do with wanting to make art without a lot of money. You know the ‘80s and the ‘90s were about making art with a lot of money. So - who’s got the better software and the higher ansi lumen projector and all that high definition stuff. I think that now there's a reaction against that, so these a lot of artists around the world, both in the west and in non western places that are wanting to kind of impoverish the work. Out of their desire to be free. You know, like, fuck it all, I just want to be free and do it myself and so if that means I'm going to do it with this material that costs zero, I’ll do it with this material that costs zero. So there's an impulse of wanting to be free from a need for expensive stuff to make art works. And that is indeed a little bit new in the sense that – not new, it comes and goes. But it’s a little bit wanting to break from those high end productions of the past ten, fifteen, twenty years. Nonetheless I would say that my own work as a curator has always been interested in – I've always been interested in works that are participatory, but I don't like works that celebrate the participatory nature. That's like the artist saying, hey look at me, I'm making this work that you can interact with. No.

TAL: Does good art propose a question or an answer?

CC-B: I think art proposes a question. Never an answer. Propaganda proposes an answer. And we are in an age that is claiming there are a lot of answers, which means we are in a very, very dangerous age.

TAL: Do you really live in a castle?

CC-B: Ha ha! I don't live in a castle! I run the program of a museum that’s located in a castle, yes. The Castello di Rivoli. You could say I live there because sometimes I'm in there until 4 am at night. When I was doing the Pierre Huyghe exhibition in Rivoli we would leave always I remember hearing the birds chirping of the dawn when we would leave the museum, the castle. So you could say I live in a castle. But I really don’t…

Labels: , ,

I Thought That...

Monday, July 14, 2008

Sam Durant, This is Freedom?, 200 Years of White Lies and End White Supremacy.
Installation view, Museum of Contemporary Art, Sydney.


The Art Life's Biennale of Sydney TV special goes to air next Tuesday, July 22 at 10pm on ABC1. In the meantime we're throwing an open invitation to our loyal blog readers to respond to the 2008 Biennale of Sydney. Liked it? Hated it? Selected highlights? Or lowlights? Send us your thoughts: theartlife[at]hotmail.com. In the meantime meantime read on for the welcome return of Ian Houston who responds below to Adrian Piper's 1993 Black Box/White Box installed as part of BOS2008 at the Art Gallery of NSW.

Labels: ,

Black & White

From Ian Houston...

Adrian Piper, Black Box/ White Box

The idea of the political in art is at once inevitable and tedious. The risk of proselytizing, the banal, the tautological and the difficulties of a cynical audience familiar with many of the strategies of artistic expression can make for a tired experience. Adrian Piper's Black Box/ White Box [1993] skirts these problems through the simple process of providing an unavoidable confrontation with the facts of a brutal incident in an arena that reminds us of our complicity in the society that sanctioned it. Thus the politics of her statement are elevated beyond the demands of ideology and become instead an ethical confrontation mediated through this aesthetic experience we know as art.



Two box shaped rooms stand in the space of the exhibition. One black, the other white. You enter the white room through a short corridor. To your left is a comfortable chair. If you sit in the chair, you will see on the screen in front of you a looped video of the incident of March 3rd 1991 in which Rodney King was beaten by eight members of the LAPD. The footage is hypnotic, fascinating. The violence sickening. To be confronted with it in the extreme austerity of this simple white room compounds its violence. In the background the Marvin Gaye song What's Going On plays under excerpts from a speech made by George Bush Snr in which he promises to provide more state troopers to deal with the riots provoked by the acquittal of the officers from the charges they faced for this assault. Beside you is a box of tissues.

A short distance away is the black room. Its dimensions and structure are equivalent to the white room though the ambience is, needless to say, darker. You sit in a chair. In front of you is a backlit, mirrored portrait of Rodney King after his beating. His face is swollen and badly cut. A tape recording of Rodney King's statement to the rioters plays on a thirty second loop. He pleads for the violence to stop, exhorting everyone to "get along." When the statement finishes, the light behind the mirror is extinguished and a spotlight focused on the viewer's chair, lights your face so that you can see yourself in the mirrored portrait. On the wall directly behind you is a framed picture of George Bush snr shaking hands with the LAPD officers after their acquittal.

Adrian Piper is an Afro American Professor of Philosophy whose field is Ethics. Her position on this event is evident. The explicit manner in which she addresses this subject seems motivated by a simple question. How can people act in this manner? There is a clinical rage at work that has distilled each element of the drama and positioned them in a relation that allows the audience not only to apprehend the inherent racism of the society but sense our complicity, that we have let such a clear instance of injustice become nothing but a media mediated memory rather than a powerfully motivating event for change. To remind us that nothing has changed to stop such an event occurring again. So the power of this work lies, not in inference, connotation and subtext but in the direct confrontation with the facts of an incident. With the unalloyed horror of a man coming to grief at the hands of a much greater force with no channels for the seeking of redress and justice. I found it to be one of the most powerful and moving works at this year's Biennale.

Adrian Piper's Black Box/ White Box is installed at the Art gallery of NSW for the 2008 Sydney Biennale.

Labels: ,

Strictly Professional

Monday, June 23, 2008
We’re feeling much better now. The past week has been one long marathon of Biennale openings, media events and chit chats with artists. Our involvement has of course been purely professional. We are working on an Art Life Biennale TV special that will screen on the ABC on July 22. Thus, our consumption of alcohol, canapés and our endless rounds of disgraceful schmoozing has all been in the name of televisual excellence.

Most people involved in the art world – especially the social side of the art scene – acknowledge that it has little to do with reality. But the distortion of this slender reality has become so extreme that we have begun to wonder why waiters are not always at our elbows... Standing in the frozen food section of Coles, we turn expecting to find a waiter at our elbows with a tray of drinks but all we see are other shoppers. Hey, where’s the booze?


Photo: Gary Grealy.

In past years the Biennale has opened on one night, a mammoth event between various venues followed by an “artist’s party” where the great and the good congregate to toast their collective beauty and genius. In 2006, the Art Gallery of NSW and The Museum of Contemporary Art opened on the same night and was followed by a party at Pier 2/3. This year someone brilliantly decided that, to avoid the unfortunate comparison between attendances at venues, there would be a staggered series of openings – Art Gallery of NSW on Monday, Museum of Contemporary Art on Tuesday, the official opening on Wednesday at midday, the artists’ party on Cockatoo Island that night, Artspace on Thursday and so on. And staggering it was.

With a guest list of 1,800 people the Cockatoo Island party was run with brutal efficiency. Ferries departed from Pier 2/3 as black clad art world worthies lined up like refugees trying to get out of a war torn land. “I have an invitation – and so does my wife!” Those without the requisite documentation were refused entry and on the slim chance that some might try to swim out, or stow away on board a Captain Cook Cruise Ship, a second line of invitation inspection was done wharf side by diminutive yet stern Biennale officials. If you were there, it was because you were meant to be there.

Enjoyment of the party seemed to be divided strictly along generational lines. Older party goers danced to a DJ whose idea of “laying down beats” was to play The Beatles Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band and double normal tempo with Tom Jones and The Art Of Noise mixed in. Young people stood to the side appalled. “It’s like a fucking school disco gone wrong!” was the caustic observation of one well known young artist. Meanwhile, a Russian artist dressed in white shirt, dark sunglasses, jeans and sneakers busted out incredible dance moves to show the kids you don’t have to be under-55 to have a good time. Indeed, the same gentleman accosted us and whispered conspiratorially “Hey, can you score me some pot, brother?”

If only we could have helped you Ivan, but we were “working”.

Labels:

Much More Than WYSIWYG

Thursday, May 22, 2008
From Isobel Johnston...

The 16th Biennale of Sydney opens in a just a few weeks ’Revolutions - forms that turn’, connecting past and present work.

Carolyn Christov-Bakargiev will bring together ‘constellations’ and encounters rather than juxtapositions- in clusters of artists. A much more ‘organic’ rather than imposed curatorship is sought by Christov-Bakargiev so this framework does not to impose itself but can be likened to a well staged dinner party which brings together the right mix of guests who in turn fire off each other to do the rest. This my understanding of the analogy given by Christov-Bakargiev at at the Art of The Curator forum recently staged at the Goethe Institute on May 12.


Do not ride bikes at night. Always wear a helmet.

It’s really also about the influence on both past and present some artists have had and where other artists have taken these influences into their own practice: to bounce off, to extend, to challenge or to dialogue. For this Biennale these encounters involve bringing together the work of older artists that have had an impact of their own contemporaries as well as on the present. Some of these artists are less well known and were not acknowledged until recently and yet their work has had this impact across both past and present. These pre-runners are joined to both their own contemporaries and to a new generation of artists whose work crosses similar terrain as constellations.

Christov-Bakargiev identifies and has established a methodology of re- presenting past and present as simultaneously contemporary - that art works of the past not only have a resonance in the present, but that they exist in the mind of a viewer who is experiencing them for the first time as contemporary [Wulf Herzogenrath at the Goethe Institute] and are melded into the fabric of that viewer’s here and now. The revolution might also be the acknowledgment of the art historical instability which has exerted itself on the cannons and perception of art history for the last four decades, as attested to in Christov-Bakargiev’s own theoretical interests and position firstly in feminism and then with arte povera. Centres no longer hold and we are all spinning into the widening gyre [ ...with apologies to WB Yeats]. A different take on this could also be in two past Biennale’s of Sydney: The Boundary Rider Biennale and Rene Block’s Readymade Boomerang.


Frank Littler, Sunrise under car No. 3, 2005.
Acrylic and oil on hardboard, 68x98cm
.


It’s 40 years since May '68 and the possibilities sought by students and workers of Paris. The conflagration of change that caught on internationally and teetered with the real possibility of change works as a perfect example of this coexistence of history and its contemporaneous other. Revolutions - forms that engage the stories, narratives and fictions that are the shifting sands of historical and contemporary truths. The connections also cut across a piece I was writing about Frank Littler’s work and seemed offer another kind of turning.

Stories is a good title for Frank Litter’s exhibition opening in Melbourne in June in a couple of weeks and overlaps the 16th Biennale of Sydney. The paintings in this show initially look quite disparate – heads, buildings, maps, caves and the aquarium but gradually the viewer becomes aware they are linked by Littler’s use of various formal and perceptual screens.

Through these screens Littler invites us into a space which lies beyond the surface of the picture plane, often an enclosed cave- like space where the visual action is taking place.. These screens are not constrained to the surface but travel through the work to intersect as much as they overlay the image. It is these points of disjuncture and rupture that draw attention to our own ‘reading’ and our own ‘seeing’ of the painting before us.

We bring what we know of the world to our reading of a painting- it happens in a moment and in the completeness of seeing but it also happens slowly and over much a longer space of time. There is the experiential and there is an analytical reading. Litter’s painting and images do something strange in that they manage to sandwich both ways of reading together and fix them in the same inseparable moment.

Littler’s use of the picture plane is at the very heart of his work – work that is about the actual language of paint and at the same time acknowledge that the works must reflect the artists own experience, interests, views and concerns. These may not be in the forefront of the artist’s mind while painting but instead pop up in the work less consciously than that.

The title is also on the other hand a bit of a ruse. These paintings are not didactic, the stories they tell are multi-layered, quirky and incomplete. You take them in as a whole, the surface, the screen, the cave like centre, the various actions the ambiguous use of space that blur the paint and its depicted forms but as to what to ‘read’ that remains open-ended.

If I could bring Littler’s work together with Max Beckman, Giorgio de Chirico and John Heartfield (artists he sites as makers of images that resonate) and I’d also add Phillip Guston and Mitch Cairns to the mix - I think Christov-Bakargiev would have another constellation. And I feel she would like the idea that just as the artists in the show dialogue, that the 16th Biennale’s dialogue extends beyond it’s own parameters to resonate; revolving to reflect on the other exhibitions and artists work just as Frank Littler’s work goes out beyond the parameters of Melbourne’s Place Gallery.

Labels: ,

What They Really Think of Us

Wednesday, March 03, 2004
Beating up on curators is like being a school bully. They are the weakest members of the art world with few friends, lots of enemies and hardly anyone who really understands what they do.

The Art Life, as a rule, thinks that the curatorial profession is misunderstood. We think that way because, if a show is done well, it seems self evident. You walk away from a show thinking it was really good and further, of course, it had to be that way didn’t it?

A bad show, on the other hand, seems clearly the fault of someone – firstly the artists cop the blame, and then it’s the curators. What were they thinking?

There have been some stinkers in Sydney over the last few years, but let’s not get into bagging them now. It’s all water under the bridge.

The funny thing about curatorial practice is that, in many ways, it ends up being irrelevant to the punters who go to the shows.

People like the work of Tracey Moffatt (for example). All her work was in one place at the MCA and you could go and see it. Who cares that much about how it was put together, or the logical (or illogical) progression from one series of works to the next? We also remember having a go at MCA curator Rachel Kent for the sheer conceptual obviousness of her Japanese show a few years back and yet, when we got down to the show and had a look at the work, we had completely forgotten about the hackneyed theme of “the city”. We were just glad to see a bunch of good art in one place.

We are very much of the school that thinks a show of recent works by artists unencumbered by an artificially concocted theme is the best way to go. The 2000 Sydney Biennale was the best example of how that approach can work.

The Biennale is a special case of course, being an experimental hot house where an idea, no matter how far out it seems, gets a go. How else can you explain crap Biennales of the 1990s like Boundary Riders, Every Day and, our anti-favourite, Jurassic Technologies Revenant? Richard Grayson’s (The World May Be) Fantastic was a throw back to earlier curatorial strategies, but it was so eccentric you were more inclined to forgive its formal repetitions than shows where you couldn’t even understand the titles, let alone the art in the shows.

Last month, the artists for the 2004 Biennale of Sydney were announced to the media and were sent out along with a page or two by curator Isabel Carlos explaining what the show will be about:

The theme, On Reason and Emotion, emerged from my reading of a thought-provoking book called “Descartes’ Error” by António Damásio. Damásio analyses a number of neurological case studies to show that emotion is crucial to human intelligence. Rather than the restrictions of the traditional “cogito” (I think, therefore I am), one can now say “I feel, therefore I am”.

Another point of departure was considering Australia as one of the southern-most continents. As a European, I have certain associations when I think of Southern cultures, and usually we connect the South with emotion, yet I have discovered Australia has much in common with the Anglo-Celtic culture of the North.


We don’t know about you, but we feel weird about European artists talking about us Southerners like that, behind our backs and, what’s more, making pretty sweeping statements about our emotional lives! For all of us who are not Anglo-Celtic, perhaps, it might even be considered completely inaccurate. But hey, everyone is entitled to their opinion and it’s good to see that Carlos has done some reading.

In the end, however, we suspect that the theme of On Reason and Emotion for this up-coming Biennale will be pretty irrelevant once you’ve dragged yourself all over town to see the art. You’ll barely remember who António Damásio is, let alone what relevance his neurological case studies have to do with the work of Joan Grounds, you’ll just remember if you liked the art or not.

Speaking of Joan Grounds, the Australian artists announced for the Biennale are an interesting lot – people who have been (mostly) untroubled by large scale institutions and exhibitions: Pat Brassington, Carolyn Eskdale, Joan Grounds & Sherre DeLys, Gordon Hookey, Derek Kreckler and Susan Norrie. If nothing else, the 2004 Biennale will give some Australian artists the chance to rub shoulders with international artists of similar (or lesser) stature to themselves.

Labels: , ,